Why do girls like feminine guys?

I'm 15, and at my junior high school there is this Guy named Jonathan who is feminine and all of my friends and every Guy know he is gay. He gets all of the attention from the girls and they love him. And every girl at my school like feminine and metrosexual guys. Why don't girls like guys that are masculine. I am hairy and can grow a goatee, but I am clean cut, I also act like a Guy. Why don't girls like masculine men anymore?